True Blue LA: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: Sounder At Heart for Seattle Sounders Fans!

Now We Really Need To Do Something

Since he's a Dodger, Nomar's injury is worse than originally anticipated. He has a micro fracture in his wrist, which will almost certainly cost him April (despite the general optimism, wrist injuries tend to take a long time to heal) and has a good chance of dropping his already poor performance for the remainder of the season. With Andy LaRoche, Tony Abreu, and Jeff Kent out right now, the Dodgers really don't have any good options to replace him. Blake Dewitt has gained attention from his strong Spring, but he really doesn't have any business being on a big league roster. Jon  Weisman has the best argument against his inclusion, saying that if Clayton Kershaw isn't considered ready after splitting time between high A and AA last year, Dewitt certainly isn't, but since I'm a bigger geek, I have numbers to back it up. Dewitt's major league equivalent stats from last year:

Inland Empire (A+, 339 AB): .247/.277/.375
Jacksonville (AA, 178 AB): .253/.277/.406

Dewitt would be a disaster if he held the job for any decent period of time, despite his strong Spring.

The most realistic in house option is Chin-Lung Hu, who would either play the position or shift Rafael Furcal over to third. However, since both of them have never played the position in their professional careers, I can't imagine that they would be great options to man the hot corner.

That leaves going outside the organization for help. Brandon Inge is probably the most productive available option thanks to his great defense, but the 19.1 million he's owed for the next three years makes him a bad temporary solution. Joe Crede provides the similar skill set of defense, decent power, and no on base ability with only a one year commitment, so he's looks to be a better option. But, is getting a guy coming off a major injury as a stopgap the best idea?

The best options seem to be Wes Helms and Esteban German. However, Helms confirmed last year that he's a platoon player (.791 OPS against left, .574 against right) and that his performance against righties in 2006 was a fluke, and would probably be a worse hitter than Dewitt most days of the week. He's also not much better than I would be defensively. This leaves German as the best option. He lacks power, but has great discipline, and would fit very well into the spot of utility guy off the bench. He's also cheap, just entering his first year of arbitration, and can be easily abandoned once we no longer need him. Only problem is that with all of these plusses, he might actually require giving someone up to get him, instead of just eating his salary like we could with any of the other options.

Without any real in house options, the Dodgers are forced to make a move to fill the gap at third base. All we can hope for is that we get someone that will be somewhat productive, and we don't give up anything of major value to get them.

Update [2008-3-20 12:2:19 by Andrew]:Ken Gurnick says Nomar could swing a bat by this weekend, but then compares his injury to the one suffered by Jayson Werth that caused him to miss a year and a half. Knowing how these things generally work, I'm not feeling optimistic about this.

Update [2008-3-20 13:47:45 by Andrew]: Joe Crede will more than likely be the White Sox third baseman this year, and since they're going for it this year for whatever reason, I take this as a sign that they think Crede is their best option. This should probably take him off the market.

0 recs  |  Comment 6 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

How about
Brandon Inge for Juan Pierre (maybe toss in some cash), does Detriot lack for a centerfielder or some speed for the top of the order?

by schoffle on Mar 19, 2008 4:54 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Re
Curtis Granderson already does both those things very well.

by Andrew on Mar 19, 2008 5:00 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Maybe
Pierre and Cash for Crede makes sense but you know Crede will be give way too much opportunity even once LaRoche is back.  

Still, not a terrible idea.  

by wiffle ball legend on Mar 19, 2008 11:54 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

or Maybe...
Scott Proctor for Wilson Betemit.

vr, Xei

by xeifrank on Mar 20, 2008 10:39 AM PDT reply actions   0 recs

No GM
Would be dumb enough to make that trade

by schoffle on Mar 20, 2008 10:47 AM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

Trade Rumor from KC
KC Star is reporting we are offering Meloan for Estaban German.

Normally I wouldn't discuss rumors like this but we do need a 3rd baseman and German has been talked about as a possible solution. Meloan seems like a bit much. I would have thought something along the lines of Troncoso and a good Low A player(Jamie Pedroza) would get it done.

I'm not at all comfortable going into the season with Abreu playing 2nd base and Hu playing 3rd base. One of the two would be fine but not both. They could both suffer huge OB problems and neither offers enough power to make up for it.

As I've said before I expect Kent to miss lots of time this year and so far he's showing no signs of proving me wrong. German is not a starting 3rd baseman but he might be a starting 2nd baseman and  I'd rather see him at 3rd base if Nomar's injury takes him out of the lineup for a few weeks.

Meloan had an excellent year in AA last year but maybe I'm missing something. He did not make the top 100 list at BA and Baseball Prospectus did not seem very enamored of him either. Derik of Baseball HQ who has Meloan as our 4th best prospect had this to say:

Strengths: 88-94 MPH two and four-seam fastballs, 85-88 MPH cut-fastball, 83-85 MPH slider, and 77-81 MPH knuckle-curve. Command. Repeating ¾ slot. Tall/strong frame

Weaknesses: Deception of 79-82 MPH change-up. Stamina (elbow)

Comments: Tall/strong-framed reliever with ability to subtract from plus fastball and two above average breaking pitches at his disposal. Repeats  delivery giving him stellar command, but likes to pitch up in the zone which could be problematic. Has mentality and power arsenal to close.

Meloan is going to be starting in AAA but I have little faith that will work out.

This team can win now, and German would be a solid addition to this team. Starting at 3rd until Nomar or LaRoche are ready, and filling in at 2nd when Kent has to sit. Then next year he can fight with Abreu for the starting 2nd base job.

Problem is I can see Nomar and LaRoche suffering production from their spring training injuries and German would not be the answer for significant time. This team will need decent production from 3rd base to battle the Diamondbacks and Rockies.

I'd say no if the price is Meloan, and wait and see if we need a longer term answer.

by Phil Gurnee on Mar 22, 2008 5:37 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

A place for Dodger fans to congregate without spending $15 on parking.
Start posting about the Dodgers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Repo-man_small
CLUTCH!™: Pulls Through to Win World Series: Overacheiving vs. Godzilla, Mediocrity, Voodoo, and Luck Narated by Screamin' Jay
Sc_white_small
It's Going to Get Worse Before It Gets Better
Ed-ak286_scully_g_20091006143938_small
An apology of sorts
Small
My Dodgers Top 200 "Prospect" Ranking
Img_0108_small
Dodger Scout Gary Nickels To Be Honored
Mratomic2_small
Is Jaime's Squeeze the New Bartman?
Sunflower_small
World Series Simulation, Game #6
Img_0108_small
New Layout Comments
Taco_man_2_small
The McCourts are Poster Children for the Credit Crunch-- Irresponsible Spending, Financed by Fans
Photo_3_small
Six Degrees of Separation

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SPONSORS


Managers

100_1427_small Phil Gurnee

Img_0108_small Eric Stephen

Editors

Bison_small David Young

Small Brendan Scolari