How about some good news?
After that negative column by Phil about the awful financial state of the franchise we need some good news so I'll try to deliver.
Many people use many projection systems. I stick with two, the Baseball Forecaster From Ron Shandler and the Pecota system from Baseball Prospectus. Between the two of them I usually get a good idea of what my expectations should be for the year in question. Most of the time I use these projection systems for my roto leagues and they must be doing something right because I'm humbly very good. This is not to say that I take what they say and take it to the bank but I do look at the process. Baseball HQ doesn't just average out the counting numbers, they look at the peripherals that created the counting numbers, they understand hit percentages, park factors, and many other peripheral stats that help make up the counting numbers.
So what does that have to do with the Dodgers? Well I received my forecaster last week and while these are just projections we should like what they say.
Good News:
1. We love our outfield, well let me tell you, they love our outfield.
On Kemp
Excellent growth season was fully supported by BPIs. BA has now exceeded xBA 4 years in a row. Power surge supported by rise in FB and HR/FB rates. Extending the 2nd half... UP: 35 HR, 120 RBI
On Andre
A breakout w/full skill support. And he did it despite deep struggles vs. LHers and on road (.238 BA, .389 Slg). PX trend and FB spike say there's more power on the horizon. UP: 40 HR, if he masters LHers.
On Manny
Before 50-game suspension, his BPI's were otherworldly. After he returned, BPIs reverted to his typical worldly level. From here, it becomes a yearly battle between skill versus age, health and motivation.
Actual Projections
| Name | Home Runs | Avg | OBA | Slug% |
| Manny | 27 | 301 | 410 | 546 |
| Kemp | 29 | 299 | 353 | 513 |
| Andre | 28 | 285 | 357 | 521 |
Okay we know the outfield was golden. Also remember that HQ only puts those little "UP" details in if they really think that player has a chance for that breakout. So now let us wander down to the infield. James Loney and his future is debated endlessly here. Eric just finished a story this week about how James has to start delivering on the promise he showed in 2006 and 2007. His PX (power index) had dropped from 132 to 117 to 91 to 70 but HQ see's some glimmers of hope.
Carbon-copy production masks some skills growth: a few more BBs, ct% trending upward. With minor recovery in h% and PX, there's a career year lurking: UP: .325, 20 HR
The actual projection is no great shakes but even if you discount the UP they are expecting an increase in the slug% from .399 to .439 (40 points).
Even 2nd base is not as dismal as I'd expected. Like many of us who looked deeper at the DeWitt season in 2009 they found that he suffered from some tough luck.
2-4-.204 in 49 AB at LA Eye provides strong foundation. What if h% was bad luck (30% in minors career)? Then he deserves a chance to recapture other skills. At age 25, has time to do so.
The projected slug% is still low but if the worse that DeWitt can do is put up a .710 OPS it will have to do. As least he's not making several million for that kind of production like Jamey Carroll will be doing. No good news here.
Consistently high LD% has helped him maintain elevated h%. xBA, ct% trending in wrong direction, though, and at age 36, SX is likely gone for good. Singles hitters with no legs have no value.
Now remember when they say "no value" they mean roto wise. Carroll has plenty of value for a bench player in MLB. His projections are nearly identical as DeWitt's except in the slug% where his .313 is about as bad as you can get. He dang well better be able to field.
Rafy Furcal looks to get a little bump back.
Easy to see now that small-sample 2008 was a fluke. 2009 was a repeat of 2007, when SX was just average (and SB variance was all in the opps). 2H provides hope that 2005-2006 can return, but SBO trend points to tired legs.
Most of the improvement is in the expected bump in his slug%.
I expected Casey Blake to get hammered in the projections given his age and health but surprisingly he's holding steady.
Hamstring problems wore him down in 2nd half. Previously healthy, so a winter's rest should fix that. Doesn't usually outperform xBA this much, so expect some BA correction. Skills are aging gently so far.
Finally we come to Russell Martin the focus of much consternation. I have to give HQ some props, they told me in the winter of 2008 that Martin did not have the peripherals to back up the power he showed in 2007. I told them they were full of hooey but they were right. Things like this are why I pay attention to HQ.
Wait, isn't he supposed to be peaking? XB hits in '09 were half of '07 totals, so both size & duration of power outage are worrisome. As a heavily used CA, are double-digit SB next? At least 2H gives a bit of hope.
The news is not exactly good here. He is expected to bounce a little but his projections still leave him woefully short of his Golden God era.
Actual Projections.
| Name | Home Runs | Avg | OBA | Slug% |
| Loney | 16 | 290 | 356 | 439 |
| DeWitt | 8 | 256 | 320 | 388 |
| Furcal | 7 | 287 | 357 | 404 |
| Blake | 18 | 275 | 349 | 459 |
| Martin | 10 | 266 | 354 | 375 |
Good thing we have a great outfield. A lot does ride on James Loney moving up his game a level. I'll do the pitching tomorrow.
63 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
By the way
I find it unbelievable that we are even talking of the possibility of Andre hitting 40 home runs, playing in Dodgers Stadium, in the post steroid world where 40 home runs really means something. I really did think he’d be a 285, 15-20 home run guy. When you are down on Loney just think of where Andre was at the same age.
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
No one seems to be expecting
big things from Kershaw next year. Mostly because of his walks. Kuroda was actually the best pitcher based on the projections.
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
If Andre Ethier hits 40 HR and masters LHP, then his nickname has to change from “3.5” to “1.”
The Ultimate Ned's Kind of Guy
Good thing he has to play three more season to gain FA.
The commenter formerly known as El Lay Dave.
Starting to seem unlikely
that any of our kids will ever get a contract doesn’t it?
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
Andre Ethier would be entering his age 31 season for 2013, and around a 128 OPS+. Maybe he’ll be a Met.
…with James “Bernie Williams” Loney in CF :)
by Eric Stephen on Dec 22, 2009 5:19 PM PST up reply actions
Worst case scenario:
Chad Billingsley becomes a Red Sox, Matt Kemp and Andre Ethier become Yankees, James Loney become a Mariner, Jonathan Broxton becomes a Cub.
At least we wil still have Kershaw
or in your doomsday scenario did he go Frank Tanana on us and blow out his arm?
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
The Dodgers will also have Carlos Zambrano in 2013, but will only have to pay $2 million of his $19.25 vested player option thanks to trading four of their top six prospects to the Cubs in order to eat salary.
by Eric Stephen on Dec 22, 2009 5:36 PM PST up reply actions
Worse
Dodger payroll is $100 million… of which $80 million is deferred salaries to players no longer on the Dodgers
The Ultimate Ned's Kind of Guy
by Humma Kavula on Dec 22, 2009 5:37 PM PST up reply actions
I meant to mention the negative side
of the HQ projections. They totally love Carlos Santana. A .863 OPS in his rookie season if he does indeed make it to the big leagues. Even more disturbing was the Tony Abreu love. A .799 OPS mostly driven by a .470 slug % from a defensive whiz at 2nd base.
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
On the other side of the coin
it is just projections and you should have seen what they thought Jay Bruce was going to do.
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
One of the least inspiring interviews ever
by Eric Stephen on Dec 22, 2009 8:27 PM PST via mobile reply actions
Where's my season ticket renewal form... oh, here it is, in the shredder.
Nah, I’m not serious. 2010 will be a fun season.
But I fear that starting in 2011-12, the Dodgers will put out an inferior product. When they do, I will have to question where my limited entertainment dollars will be spent.
The Ultimate Ned's Kind of Guy
by Humma Kavula on Dec 22, 2009 8:37 PM PST up reply actions
The Dodgers won’t be able to afford everyone salaries because the arbitration board won’t allow the Dodgers to defer half of the players salaries. :)
They don't go to arbitration if the player agrees to a contract.
“Matt, we love you, and honestly, we think you’re worth the 6 million that you’ll be submitting to the arb board. In fact, we think you’re worth more — how does $1 million per year over the next seven years sound?”
The Ultimate Ned's Kind of Guy
by Humma Kavula on Dec 22, 2009 8:42 PM PST up reply actions
this interview
confirms how utterly f*cked we are, what a bunch of b.s. and fluff from Mannion, his attempt to cover up the financial problems just made it even more obvious. I really hope the whole city reads right through this, and the fans call for his head soon. Please God bring us Cuban or Broad
William Doolittle at your service, a.k.a. will do.
We're screwed
This Mannion guy is a BUFFOON. He makes it sound like they’d rather spend money on portable concession stands than amateur talent.
There is a cliche in PR: “If you don’t tell your story, someone else will tell it for you.” That is why you participate in an interview like this — you have a chance to spin the story your way.
That is not what happened in this interview. Mannion screwed the pooch. He was not properly prepared.
Whoever set up the interview will suffer.
The Ultimate Ned's Kind of Guy
by Humma Kavula on Dec 22, 2009 8:50 PM PST up reply actions
Bill Shaikin isn’t exactly a bulldog. He is not T.J. Simers. Hell even T.J. Simers will allow you tell your story(Whatever you think about his Jamie McCourt interview, she did get her point across. )
That's precisely my point.
He had a great opportunity here. He blew it.
Maybe he’s just inexperienced at being the point man in interviews. Or maybe he wasn’t prepared.
Either way, whoever set up the interview — whether they deserve it or not — will suffer.
The Ultimate Ned's Kind of Guy
by Humma Kavula on Dec 22, 2009 8:54 PM PST up reply actions
Shaikin might not be a bulldog
but for the most part, he asked precisely on point questions – and followed up. I’m not sure what went on with Mannion, but Shaikin didn’t give him a cakewalk.
Where was the followup?
He made a huge general comment about all the reasons why we think the Dodgers have financial problems and Mannion failed to address any of them. And then says actions will allay those concerns, well Mr. Mannion your actions are the points that Bill was talking about.
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
by Phil Gurnee on Dec 22, 2009 10:21 PM PST up reply actions
Example of a followup
“Are you saying your choice could be between spending on amateur talent and spending on portable concession stands?”
Look, if you’re looking for a “You can’t handle the truth!” moment, it’s not there. Everything’s relative. But this is the biggest grilling that a Dodger executive has had in some time. Mannion is not an incompetent man – I don’t think it’s an accident that Shaikin got him to say incompetent things. I don’t think it’s an accident that Mannion, who clearly entered the interview with the intention of painting a rosier picture of the Dodgers, left the interview having painted a muddier one.
Yes
that followup was excellent and one Mannion will regret for years, especially if the Dodgers invest in portable concession stands in the near future.
I just felt that Shalkin asked the right questions but when Mannion avoided most of them he didn’t come back for specifics. I know many of us are asking what is the deal with the Schmidt report. I still have no clue what that was all about and I’d loved to have heard more about that point.
Still I don’t think I was complaining about the interviewer, he certainly did ask the right questions. I don’t know to many Dodger fans who can come away from this interview and feel very positive about the fact Mannion is now running the day to day operations of the team.
I know I’m depressed.
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
by Phil Gurnee on Dec 22, 2009 10:50 PM PST up reply actions
I agree that asked the tough questions,
and I think the total bs responses Mannion gave definitely confirm how bad the situation really is
William Doolittle at your service, a.k.a. will do.
And is it worth a premium draft pick? That’s also showing bizarre behavior, in my opinion, in terms of teams bidding against themselves for draft picks. That’s been going on for a while on the amateur side of the business. But it’s happening now on the international side, with guys you don’t know anything about.
Frightening
by Julio Nievas on Dec 22, 2009 9:38 PM PST up reply actions
http://sports.espn.go.com/los-angeles/columns/story?columnist=jackson_tony&id=4755875
Tony Jackson asks where is Manny. Uh, in Florida where he lives off season?
Mannion
Is there anything other than action in your mind that is going to be able to convince fans that this organization is not limited by severe cost controls, given all the things we’ve talked about?
I think actions are the only way to speak to it.
Are you convinced you’ll be able to show enough action soon?
I would hope so.
And to quote Bill Shalkin even though it looks like he took some of this right from us. These are the actions that the fans have seen. So Dennis if these are your actions the fans already know what the situation is. Spin away, were not idiots.
* Deferred more than $45 million in player salaries, most of that with Manny Ramirez
* Traded top prospects in lieu of picking up contracts
* Declined to bid on virtually every top free agent
* Declined to bid on top international prospects
* Spent fewer dollars than any other club in the last two drafts
* Delayed playoff ticket refunds this year
* Fired more than a dozen employees
* Didn’t re-invest $19 million from the Jason Schmidt insurance payment and the Manny Ramirez suspension into baseball operations
* Deferred renovations to the loge and reserve levels, beyond center field and in the clubhouses
No one action raises a red flag, but doesn’t the totality of events suggest the Dodgers are experiencing financial trouble?
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
New information:
1. Delayed Playoff Refunds
2. Didn’t reinvest 19 Million from the Jason Schmidt insurance payment and the Manny Ramirez suspension into baseball operations.
WTF on item 2. As Tripon said, what does that mean? Where else could the money go? McCourt can’t just pocket that money, he’s bound by the salary according to provisions in the loans with BofA. Any help from someone on this item would be beneficial.
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
So .much for this being a good news post
I guess that is what you call a fluid post, as we figure out best where to use our TBLA assets. We are going to defer some of our posts until 2010 as we recalibrate where we stand. TBLA may need some portable concession stands.
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
I was looking at the 2010 draft order and was amazed to see that the Angels currently have * FIVE * picks in the top 37, including 3 in the top 30. That’ll re-stock a farm system.
They will need to
given the loss of talent at the big league level. Just in the last two years
1. Teixeira
2. Vlady
3. Figgins
4. Lackey
5. Frankie
Man that is a good part of an all-star team.
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
by Phil Gurnee on Dec 22, 2009 10:53 PM PST up reply actions
There's only 3 Type A free agents left
Holliday
Bay
Valverde
Obviously, we’re not signing the first two. So our 1st round pick is safe, unless…..nah, nevermind.
jamey carroll
why didn’t he keep that $4 million too? for some reason this signing just incenses me… pierre, andruw jones, even mark f*king loretta you could at least understand what they were TRYING to do….
this signing was, dare I say, sabeanesque?
by lchristmas on Dec 22, 2009 11:24 PM PST via mobile reply actions
“His intellectual shortcomings are obvious,” one political observer notes. “We don’t know of one project that Raul Mondesi has submitted.”
First elected in 2006 to the Chamber of Deputies — the Dominican equivalent of the U.S. House of Representatives — as a member of President Leonel Fernandez’s Dominican Liberation Party, or PLD, Mondesi jumped to the opposition Dominican Revolutionary Party, or PRD, during his second term.
The PRD rewarded that decision by backing his campaign for mayor of San Cristobal, surrounding him with a cabal of lawyers and professionals who arrived for a campaign meeting at Mondesi’s nightclub and car wash recently wearing crisp white polo shirts with the candidate’s name on them. Mondesi, looking as trim and fit as he did during three consecutive 30-home-run seasons with the Dodgers a decade ago, arrived nearly an hour later in a glistening white Mercedes S600, wearing a button-up shirt and a fishing hat and wanting to talk about alleviating poverty.
“Most of the people, they don’t have anything,” said Mondesi, who grew up in crushing circumstances just a few miles away. “I know what they need, how they feel.”
Asked for specifics, however, and the closest he comes to a campaign pledge is repeating a desire to build a basketball court in every neighborhood.
Facepalm.
http://www.latimes.com/news/nation-and-world/la-fg-dominican-mondesi23-2009dec23,0,105815.story
Holy shit, Mondesi’s political opponent is Jose Rijo. Yes, the one who was caught up in the betting scandal.
Imagine if a bunch of so-so retired major leaguers were in the US government today! We would be even more screwed.
not as screwed as if we had major league owners in the U.S. government
or a certain major league commissioner, for that matter…















