The Dodger Play-By-Play Candidates
This spring the Dodgers have been auditioning candidates to be the secondary play-by-play announcer, for the games Vin Scully doesn't broadcast. Generally, Scully doesn't travel east of Colorado except for special occasions. By my count, there are 42 41 such games this season:
- April 21-23: 3 games in Houston
- May 12-17: 3 games in Philadelphia, 3 games in Florida
- May 28-31: 4 games at Wrigley Field (final game is ESPN Sunday Night game)
- June 12-14: 3 games in Texas
- June 23-25: 3 games at Comiskey Park
- July 7-12: 3 games in New York, 3 games in Milwaukee
- July 27-August 2: 4 games in St. Louis, 3 games in Atlanta
- August 28-30: 3 games in Cincinnati
- September 22-28: 3 games in Washington, 4 games in Pittsburgh
In the last few years, Charley Steiner served as the secondary television play-by-play man in addition to working the radio broadcasts with Rick Monday in the other games. However, the Dodgers announced in December that Steiner and Monday would broadcast all games on radio this season, creating the opening for the new TV play-by-play job. Steve Lyons will serve as the television analyst for these non-Scully games.
Here is a look at the six candidates for this position:
Joe Block: Currently works for Comcast as a football, basketball, and baseball announcer, and also serves as radio studio host for the New Orleans Hornets. Block also worked radio play-by-play for the Montreal Expos, and was the announcer for former Dodger minor league affiliate Jacksonville Suns from 2003-2006 (hat tip to Eric Enders for this tidbit).
Eric Collins: Has worked for ESPN and ABC Sports, primarily announcing college football, but also has college baseball experience as well. He also announced baseball and basketball in the Beijing Olympics for NBC last summer.
Tom Hart: Currently works for CBS College Sports, primarily announcing football and basketball. According to his bio, "Hart also spent nine summers calling minor league baseball for the farm clubs of the Diamondbacks, Cardinals, Blue Jays, White Sox, and Mets and is a two-time winner of the Southern League Broadcaster of the Year Award."
Ken Levine: He is the co-host of DodgerTalk on KABC 790, as well as an accomplished television comedy writer. Levine has worked TV and radio play-by-play for the Baltimore Orioles, Seattle Mariners, and San Diego Padres.
Josh Suchon: He is also a co-host of DodgerTalk, and in addition to working as play-by-play man for the Modesto Nuts for a year, Suchon was a beat writer for the Giants, then the A's, for seven years. Please don't hold it against him that he once wrote a book about Barry Bonds, entitled "This Gracious Season: Barry Bonds & The Greatest Year in Baseball."
Ben Wagner: For the last two years, he served as play-by-play man for the AAA Buffalo Bisons. He announced for the single-A Lakewood BlueClaws, then a Phillies affiliate, three years before that. At 28 years old, Wagner is the youngest of the six candidates.
I really like Levine; I think he is hilarious. He and Suchon have a good chemistry and rapport on DodgerTalk, though, and in this case that works against him since I don't want to break them up. My favorite of the six candidates is Joe Block. I like his voice and his announcing style. Plus, I like the fact that he was there for the "Jacksonville Five." Of the current 40-man roster of the Dodgers, 14 played in Jacksonville during Block's tenure there. I like the potential perspective he might bring to the Dodgers' announcing booth.
0 recs |
14 comments
|
Comments
I'm for Levine, too
Block does have the Mr. Radio Guy voice, but I think there’s a risk of that becoming obnoxious with extended exposure. Especially if he isn’t funny, which he manifestly wasn’t when I’ve heard him. Not a big fan of Suchon’s, and I didn’t like Wagner much when I heard him. Still haven’t heard Collins or Hart.
I’m willing to change my worthless vote to anybody who promises not to talk about steroids. Also, I like Your Mom jokes. So, keep that in mind, future contestants.
by Andrew Shimmin on Mar 13, 2009 8:32 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Would you settle for...
…the ever-popular “Your mom is so jacked up on roids, she…” line of humor?
Also, I’m not sure how they are scheduling the rest of the PBP, but so far at least five of the six have worked, and I believe Levine is up next.
by Eric Stephen on Mar 13, 2009 8:54 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
I hate Charlie Steiner
I don’t care who replaces the guy, I’m just glad Steiner is off TV. I hate that guy. He always determines the outcome of the play BEFORE it’s over. It just happened the other day on a WBC game:
“And an easy ground ball out to the… NO! He’s safe!”
For cryin’ out loud, wait until the play is OVER before you call it an out.
by EthierIsBetterThanKemp on Mar 13, 2009 9:42 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Devil's advocate
Maybe the ball was an easy grounder, that would probably be an out 99% of the time. I didn’t hear the call though so I don’t want to comment.
I like Steiner, but I don’t care for his excitement over fly ball outs (potential homers of course).
by Eric Stephen on Mar 13, 2009 10:06 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
It's about time this man got his shot...
My vote went to Joe Block. Block brings to the table a lot of experience in baseball announcing and has worked before with the dodger organization. I tuned into him Friday afternoon and I thought that there was some chemistry for him on the big stage. I personally got the chance to meet Mr. Block on a trip to Jacksonville a few summers ago and he is a great man with a knowledge for the game unlike anyone I had ever seen before. I think he also has an advantage were he to get this job since there are a lot of guys playing for the dodgers now that he announced for in Jacksonville. It’s about time Joe got the call from radio to the TV and fills his dream of being a big league announcer.
by TheJet on Mar 13, 2009 10:02 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Levine
Levine was really, really good the other day. He has character, that comes through his expression and his anecdotes, like Vin. And he’s funny from time to time. And with all this, not in any way obnoxious. I found Joe Block accurate, calm and reasonable, which is something, and very, very dull, which is not.
by berkowit28 on Mar 14, 2009 9:27 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Levine would be a fine choice
Levine’s humor and personality are his greatest assets, and he would be great. I guess I’m trying to be a bit selfish, since if Block wins the job Levine will still be on DodgerTalk. :)
by Eric Stephen on Mar 14, 2009 10:41 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Wagner is Solid
I was stunned to read the Buffalo guy is only 28. He sounded smooth and has a great voice. I hope they pick this guy. An up and comer.
by Loneytic12 on Mar 14, 2009 10:28 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Voted for Levine
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
by Phil Gurnee on Mar 14, 2009 12:38 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Wagner
I listened to Ben Wagner for 2 years during Lakewood broadcasts, and he is a solid, well prepared man who continues to get better every year. He would make a FINE choice.
by Lakewood Superfan on Mar 17, 2009 8:24 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Wagner
I’ve been friends with Ben Wagner since college. I used to listen to his games then. He was clearly the best that a college radio station could hope to have. Even back then his preparation seemed to me what set him apart. I know my view is biased but I hope he gets the job. I think you’ll all enjoy him if he does. I’m pretty sure he’ll get a full time MLB job one of these days.
by IndyCardsFan on Mar 18, 2009 6:00 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
I don't believe it
Can you guys ascertain if there are 519 separate people (OK, computers) voting for Wagner – or if you even have 519 readers? (Congratulations if so!) Or could a few people be stuffing the ballot box by repeat voting? I don’t believe that 519 people who are regular Dodgers fans and readers of this site are voting.
I see you now have this post set up so that computers that have already voted cannot vote again – only the results show. But I seem to recall that that was not always the case – am I right? Even now, people can probably vote again by removing cookies, or just this site’s cookie, from their browser. Yes?
by berkowit28 on Mar 20, 2009 10:21 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
re:
They have to be unique IP Addresses. Go ahead and try to vote and you will not be able to from the same IP Address. We now have about 1500-2000 unique readers each day and over 600 who have taken the time to register.
However it would be easy to stuff the ballot if someone passed the link in an effort to make a difference. If Ben Wagner has enough fans that they have taken the time to vote then hats off to him that they care enough to come to a site they would not normally visit and vote for him.
by meercatjohn on Mar 20, 2009 10:50 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Wagner
Ben’s got a great voice and a clear understanding of the art of telling a story as it unfolds before him. His preparation and tact with players are both supurb and his delivery is better than some seasoned vets. I’ve heard a couple of the other guys on this list and Ben’s better most of the time. Remember he’s very young so he’ll only get better. I look forward to having him in our booth… but if not with us, he’ll be “called up” sometime soon. Get this hard working young man before someone else does!
by LADodgers on Mar 22, 2009 10:23 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs

by 














