It is time to play - Name the BA Top 30
Here's a weekend game to play, just received my copy of the 2012 Baseball America Prospect book so here's the game you loved to play last year, name the top 30 (and 31st) Dodger prospects by the hints I give.
Now, last month, BA published the Dodger top ten prospects so I will give their grades and risks (described here) that BA is using in the book.
1. RHP Zach Lee - 60/Medium
2. RHP Allen Webster - 55/Medium
3. RHP Nate Eovaldi - 55/Medium
4. OF Alfredo Silverio - 55/Medium
5. LHP Chris Reed - 55/Medium
6. RHP Garrett Gould - 55/Medium
7. RHP Chris Withrow - 55/High
8. RHP Josh Limblom - 50/Low9. OF Joc Pederson - 50/High
10. Tim Federowicz - 45/Low
11. Raw, strong defense - 50/High
12. Power arm, no mechanical issues, potential no. 3 - 50/High
13. Above-average power, struggles to maintain consistency - 50/Extreme
14. Sits 90-93, touches 94, projectable frame - 50/High
15. Herky-jerky delivery, ceiling as a set up man - 50/High
16. Incomplete season - 50/High
17. Lack of command but array of promising pitches - 55/Extreme
18. Young, intriguing tools - 50/High
19. Potential for average power, above average speed and good arm - 45/Medium
20. Draws comparison to another player with one of his names - 45/Medium
21. Solid power to all fields, adequate defensively - 45/Medium
22. Gap power may not equal HR, lacks speed and athleticism - 45/Medium
23. Better pure stuff than his brother - 50/Extreme
24. Troncoso replacement (my words) - 45/High
25. Good pitch recognition skills, more raw than usual for his position - 45/High
26. He's still here (my words) - 40/Low
27. Nothing flashy about his game, consistent defender - 40/Medium
28. Size may be an issue, contact-oriented approach - 45/High
29. Sound swing, generates plus bat speed, defense is fine - 45/High
30. Above-average power, test will be next level - 45/High
31. Former intern - 45/High
61 comments
|
2 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
12 = Sanchez
13 = Garcia
16 = Aaron Miller
23 = Sullivan
26 = DeJesus
30 = Songco
22 – Van Slyke
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
pretty good
Several of these are right
by bhsportsguy on Jan 28, 2012 12:29 PM PST via iPhone app up reply actions
or 11 for Santana
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
by Phil Gurnee on Jan 28, 2012 11:48 AM PST up reply actions
sounds right
Do you see Kyle Russell on that list?
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
by Phil Gurnee on Jan 28, 2012 12:34 PM PST up reply actions
Might be 13
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
by Phil Gurnee on Jan 28, 2012 12:35 PM PST up reply actions
Or Blake Smith
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
by Phil Gurnee on Jan 28, 2012 12:37 PM PST up reply actions
some are you
Are right. I am out now but I will recap later.
by bhsportsguy on Jan 28, 2012 12:28 PM PST via iPhone app reply actions
11 and 18
Baldwin or Santana for either spot?
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
I expected more pitchers, don’t see a spot for Cash based on the hints unless he was 16 and Aaron Miller is gone but I don’t believe that.
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
Summing up
11 – Baldwin
12 – Sanchez
13 – J. Garcia
15 – Tolleson
16 – Miller
17 – Martin
18 – Santana
23 – O’Sullivan
26 – DeJesus, Jr.
More hints (location is BA prediction)
14. Sits 90-93, touches 94, projectable frame – 50/High (Ogden is likely destination)
19. Potential for average power, above average speed and good arm – 45/Medium (AAA))
20. Draws comparison to another player with one of his names – 45/Medium (AAA)
21. Solid power to all fields, adequate defensively – 45/Medium (AAA)
22. Gap power may not equal HR, lacks speed and athleticism – 45/Medium (AA)
24. Troncoso replacement (my words) – 45/High (AAA/AA)
25. Good pitch recognition skills, more raw than usual for his position – 45/High (Midwest A)
27. Nothing flashy about his game, consistent defender – 40/Medium! (AA)
28. Size may be an issue, contact-oriented approach – 45/High (AA)
29. Sound swing, generates plus bat speed, defense is fine – 45/High (Midwest A)
30. Above-average power, test will be next level – 45/High (AA)
31. Former intern – 45/High (ultimately California League at least)
14 = Brandon Martinez
19 = Alex Castellanos
21 = Scott Van Slyke
22 = Angelo Songco
24 = Stephen Fife
27 = Jake Lemmerman
30 = Blake Smith
by silverwidow on Jan 28, 2012 11:46 PM PST up reply actions
Nope
All 4 guesses are not on their Top 31 list
by bhsportsguy on Jan 29, 2012 12:14 AM PST up reply actions
Updated
11 – Baldwin
12 – Sanchez
13 – J. Garcia
15 – Tolleson
16 – Miller
17 – Martin
18 – Santana
19 – Castellanos
21 – Van Slyke
22 – Songco
23 – O’Sullivan
26 – DeJesus, Jr.
27 – Lemmerman
30 – B. Smith
Next set of hints
14. Sits 90-93, touches 94, projectable frame – 50/High (Ogden is likely destination), RHP, 19
20. Draws comparison to another player with one of his names – 45/Medium (AAA), LH position player, 25
24. Troncoso replacement (my words) – 45/High (AAA/AA), RHP, 25
25. Good pitch recognition skills, more raw than usual for his position – 45/High (Midwest A) LH position player, 22
28. Size may be an issue, contact-oriented approach – 45/High (AA), Bats Both position player, 24
29. Sound swing, generates plus bat speed, defense is fine – 45/High (Midwest A), RH position player, 22
31. Former intern – 45/High (ultimately California League at least), LHP, 24
14 = Scott Barlow
24 = Josh Wall
25 = Scott Schebler
28 = Griff Erickson
29 = O’Koyea Dickson
by silverwidow on Jan 29, 2012 12:26 AM PST up reply actions
It's sad to see Kyle Russell so low with his power potential
TBLA 2011 Postseason Prediction Champion
Players that dropped off Baseball America's Top 30 Dodger Prospects
From 2011 are:
11 – Leon Landry
19 – Brian Cavazos-Galvez
20 – Ralston Cash
22 – Pedro Baez
23 – Scott Schebler
29 – Derek Cone
30 – Luis Vasquez
6 players played enough in the majors in 2011 to no longer be considered prospects and 1 player (Robinson) was traded.
Wow Landry from 11 to nada
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
by Phil Gurnee on Jan 29, 2012 11:30 AM PST up reply actions
I thought Derek Cone was on the list last year?
Patience is for those who die waiting for something to happen
by Phil Gurnee on Jan 29, 2012 12:12 PM PST up reply actions
Updated again
11 – Baldwin
12 – Sanchez
13 – J. Garcia
14 – Barlow
15 – Tolleson
16 – Miller
17 – Martin
18 – Santana
19 – Castellanos
21 – Van Slyke
22 – Songco
23 – O’Sullivan
24 – Wall
26 – DeJesus, Jr.
27 – Lemmerman
28 – Erickson
29 – Dickson
30 – B. Smith
20 = Kyle Russell
That’s it for me. 25 & 31 are tough…
by silverwidow on Jan 29, 2012 12:42 AM PST up reply actions
Kyle Russell
Is right, the player he was compared to was Russell Branyan
by bhsportsguy on Jan 29, 2012 12:54 AM PST up reply actions
3 left
Only one of them was on Baseball America’s 2011 Top 30 Dodger Prospects. The other two at this time last year were playing college ball.
25
Makes sense if only due to where he was drafted. I am pretty positive that only Brandon knows who the player is that sits at 31.
Number 31
Is LHP Eric Eadington. Eric was signed as an undrafted free agent and pitched well in relief albeit as a 23 year old college pitcher in Arizona 18 K in 11 IP with 10 hits and 6 walks and then going to Ogden, 13/2 K/BB in 10 IP. Reportedly throws 90-94 fastball, second pich is a breaking ball about 11 MPH slower.
Eadington, Corona Del Mar native, has a Economics degree from Harvard. Both of his sisters are collegiate water polo players, his older sister graduated from Cal in 2008 and his younger sister is a sophomore at Santa Clara.
His BA profile mentions he was an office intern for the Dodgers but the article doesn’t mention what he did there.
My guesses without looking at comments.
11. Baldwin
12. Miller
13. Songco
14. Sanchez
15. McGough
16. If 12 isn’t Miller, then this one has to be him. If not him….did Lemmerman have an incomplete season? I can’t fgure where else he’d go.
17. Martin, as always.
18. Santana
19. Garcia
21. Blake Smith
22. Kyle Russell?
23. O’Sullivan
24. Justin Miller
26. Dejesus
@TElciram

by 



















