Here are the lineups for Game 4:
| Yankees | Phillies | |||
| SS | Jeter | SS | Rollins |
|
| LF |
Damon | CF | Victorino |
|
| 1B | Teixeira | 2B | Utley | |
| 3B | A-Rod | 1B | Howard | |
| C | Posada | RF | Werth |
|
| 2B | Cano | LF | Ibañez |
|
| RF | Swisher | 3B | Feliz |
|
| CF | Cabrera | C | Ruiz | |
| P | Sabathia | P | Blanton |
|