clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Jeff Bagwell is to James Loney as Pedro Martinez is to Chad Billingsley?

New, comments

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

Before there were such things as CHONE, Pecota, and Bill James' annual projection for players, there was a charming little thing called Similarity Scores, also created by Bill James.  If you look at, you will find a description of the formula used for similarity scores and a credit to James' book The Politics of Glory; however, I first read about them in The Bill James Baseball Abstract 1986, in which he introduced the concept, having worked on it over the past year.  This was also the book that introduced me to the term sabermetrics, among other things.

I stumbled across The Bill James Baseball Abstract 1986 while looking in a book store for a book that contained all the major league statistics for the 1985 season (no in those days), which I needed to prepare for a Strat-O-Matic baseball draft.  (I went with a HR friendly ballpark and loaded up on power, defense be damned, and drafted Pedro Guerrero #1 at 3B/1B.)  The book was an eye-opener in many ways and made me aware that there were a lot of ways to look at baseball and baseball statistics than just the traditional versions.  I wonder if I would have even gravitated toward the baseball blogs that I enjoy so much today had I never crossed paths with James' Abstract. By the way, in the Dodgers chapter, James defends Lasorda's decision to pitch to Jack Clark.

If you didn't read the formula in the link, the brief version is that 1000 is a perfect match between two players.  Points are then deducted from there based on differences in position, a bunch of counting statistics (e.g., hits) and a few ratios (e.g., batting average, ERA).  Obviously, the higher the number, the better the match.

At, they calcluate the similarity scores on each player's page, giving the top-10 career similarities, plus the top-10 at each age of the player's career, near the bottom of the page.  For example, if you scroll toward the bottom of ex-Dodger Shawn Green's player page, you'll find that his number one match in career similarity score is ex-Dodger Reggie Smith at 945.  This is what similarity scores (using this formula) seem to work best for, evaluating player production over an entire career, which is good for things like Hall of Fame arguments.  You'll also see that at age 29, after his last great season (2002), the 29-year old he was most similar to was Dale Murphy with a similarity score of 942.

Similarity scores don't make for a particularly great projection system, because, among other things, the stats used aren't the best for that purpose and the similarities don't account for trends (i.e., improving or not), but I'd bet that Bill James used similarity studies with different stats in play to fine tune his projection system.  However, that doesn't stop the age-based similarity score summaries at from being a lot of fun to peruse and to compare current players to players throughout baseball history and see how that current player might turn out.  This turns out to be a fine time to do such a thing because a) the season is over and the hot stove is still thawing out, and b) just updated them all to include the 2009 season data.

After the jump are similarity score summaries for the selected returning Dodger players at their 2009-season age.  These show the top ten similar players at the same age - some of the names may surprise you:

UPDATE - corrected lists for Russell Martin, Rafael Furcal, and Casey Blake. The previous lists were incorrect due to a bug regarding position adjustments in the software that was present at the time this article was originally written. I left the incorrect tables below as well, just for the curiosity of seeing things like Bobby Grich in Russell Martin's list.
Corrected Tables
Russell Martin, Age 26 Casey Blake, Age 35 Rafael Furcal, Age 31
Similar Player Similarity Score Similar Player Similarity Score Similar Player Similarity Score
Thurman Munson 966 Aaron Boone 938 Craig Biggio 934
Sammy White 956 Melvin Mora 930 Jay Bell 921
Ray Fosse 942 Jim Hickman 911 Tony Fernandez 910
Ed McFarland 941 Dave Hollins 910 Ray Durham 900
Rich Gedman 933 Charlie Maxwell 909 Barry Larkin 895
Yadier Molina 932 Jim Lemon 908 Cristian Guzman 893
Benito Santiago 932 Mel Hall 907 Herman Long 887
Jack Clements 930 Hoot Evers 905 Orlando Cabrera 885
Tim McCarver 926 Jay Payton 903 Lou Whitaker 885
Bob O'Farrell 926 Kevin Millar 902 Frankie Crosetti 885

Original Tables
Russell Martin, Age 26 James Loney, Age 25 Rafael Furcal, Age 31
Similar Player Similarity Score Similar Player Similarity Score Similar Player Similarity Score
Thurman Munson 971 Jeff Bagwell 975 Craig Biggio 944
Felipe Lopez 966 Ted Kluszewski 974 Ray Durham 940
Mike Andrews 963 Alvin Davis 960 Jay Bell 921
Sammy White 962 Joe Hauser 948 Lou Whitaker 920
Ray Durham 960 Babe Young 943 Jason Kendall 920
Lonny Frey 960 Rafael Palmeiro 939 Delino DeShields 916
Gil McDougald 960 George Kelly 939 Chuck Knoblauch 915
Aaron Ward 954 Steve Garvey 939 Brian Roberts 914
Bobby Grich 953 Joe Adcock 936 Tony Fernandez 910
Barry Larkin 951 Adrian Gonzalez 935 Paul Molitor 909
Casey Blake, Age 35 Manny Ramirez, Age 37 Juan Pierre, Age 31
Similar Player Similarity Score Similar Player Similarity Score Similar Player Similarity Score
Aaron Boone 938 Ken Griffey, Jr. 857 Willie Wilson 943
Melvin Mora 930 Jimmie Foxx 849 Clyde Milan 916
Jim Hickman 911 Frank Robinson 840 Max Carey 910
Dave Hollins 910 Rafael Palmeiro 813 Duff Cooley 908
Charlie Maxwell 909 Barry Bonds 812 George Case 904
Jason Varitek 909 Gary Sheffield 811 George Burns 903
Jim Lemon 908 Jim Thome 811 Steve Brodie 896
Mel Hall 907 Jeff Bagwell 810 Ginger Beaumont 892
Hoot Evers 905 Chipper Jones 803 Harry Hooper 884
Jay Payton 903 Willie Mays 800 Mickey Rivers 873
Matt Kemp, Age 24 Andre Ethier, Age 27 Clayton Kershaw, Age 21
Similar Player Similarity Score Similar Player Similarity Score Similar Player Similarity Score
Nick Markakis 971 Richie Zisk 971 Britt Burns 972
Carlos Beltran 961 Bobby Higginson 970 Moe Drabowsky 971
Vernon Wells 960 Sam Chapman 966 John Henry Johnson 971
Enos Slaughter 955 Aubrey Huff 962 Jack Fisher 970
Ellis Burks 954 Jacque Jones 961 Carl Cashion 970
Bobby Bonds 945 Bill Nicholson 959 Ken Holtzman 969
Ellis Valentine 944 Jim Edmonds 957 Norm Baker 968
Rocco Baldelli 944 Jason Giambi 957 Jerry Walker 966
Bug Holliday 941 Larry Doby 953 Dontrelle Willis 966
Andre Dawson 938 Reggie Sanders 951 Mike Witt 965
Chad Billingsley, Age 24 Hiroki Kuroda, Age 34 Jonathan Broxton, Age 25
Similar Player Similarity Score Similar Player Similarity Score Similar Player Similarity Score
Ray Culp 977 Masato Yoshii 966 Doug Bird 961
Pedro Martinez 975 Sig Jakucki 959 Chad Cordero 958
Jake Peavy 973 Walt Dickson 957 Roger McDowell 958
Stan Williams 970 Kenshin Kawakami 950 Huston Street 956
Sid Fernandez 966 Frank Oberlin 949 Victor Cruz 956
Carlos Zambrano 965 Jimmy Zinn 948 Steve Bedrosian 953
Dennis Martinez 965 Lou Tost 946 Antonio Osuna 953
Scott Kazmir 963 Art Delaney 946 Luis DeLeon 953
Dave McNally 961 Bob Keegan 945 Scott Williamson 951
Ramon Martinez 959 Tom Filer 944 Tom Niedenfuer 950
Hong-Chih Kuo, Age 27 George Sherrill, Age 32 Ramon Troncoso, Age 26
Similar Player Similarity Score Similar Player Similarity Score Similar Player Similarity Score
Hank Aguirre 982 Ricardo Rincon 967 Scott Sullivan 988
Rich Folkers 981 Pedro Feliciano 962 Jack Wisner 985
Gene Walter 978 Rich Rodriguez 960 Gary Wagner 984
Juan Agosto 977 Tony Castillo 956 Roy Thomas 984
Dick Kelley 976 Steve Frey 950 Jack Billingham 984
Greg Cadaret 975 Kerry Ligtenberg 949 Brandon Medders 982
Rafael Perez 975 Graeme Lloyd 949 Bobby Locke 982
Ken Frailing 975 Tom Hilgendorf 946 Hersh Freeman 981
Pedro Martinez 975 Mike James 943 George Frazier 981
Dave Leiper 974 Jim Hughes 942 Toby Borland 981


Did I acknowledge enough?